Once more into the breach. Equipment: For Region A domestic and import discs, Playstation 3 console. For Region B import discs, OPPO BDP 83. Display: Hitachi P50V701, 16:9 Standard 2 Aspect Ratio setting, Day (Dynamic) picture setting, reset by eye by author using Lawrence of Arabia film still in Kevin Brownlow’s David Lean biography as guide. And the Hitachi set crapped out for good after I completed the viewing notes for this column, so I am again compelled to mention this blog has a tip jar, alas.
Alice (BFI Import)
Surrealism-inflected Czech animator Jan Svankmajer has made a good number of outstanding, and eccentric and savagely beautiful films, but this cracked consideration of Lewis Carroll is considered his defining work by many, and not without good reason; the juxtaposition of Carroll’s gentle but sly oddball sensibility with the adapter’s often more visceral eccentricities makes for a uniquely bracing end product. This BFI Blu-ray looks pretty great. A key detail: the film is narrated by the title character (played by Kristyna Kohoutova) in a tight live-action closeup of her mouth, and the chapping on her lips increases and decreases visibly from narration sequences to narrations sequence. The tea party scene is particularly incredible, and what this high-def transfer captures so beautifully besides colors are the textures that are so important to Svankmajer’s art: Fur, paint slathered/dabbed on wood/cardboard, etc.—A+
The Big Country (MGM/UA Walmart exclusive)
This 1958 William Wyler semi-epic is the kind of picture that makes some people sit up and say, “Now THAT’S a Western,” but you know us auteurists and quasi-auteurists, even those of us who love, say, Dodsworth: when it comes to this genre, we put Mr. Wyler in line WAY in back of Ford, Hawks, Mann, Boetticher, et.al., and even then, when we get started we prefer The Westerner. But as I frequently say, this is a Blu-ray Consumer Guide, not a movie one, and this disc is beautiful. There is grain here, and the contrast between particular shots is pronounced in an interesting way that reflects the process of shooting such big-ticket action pictures; there’s a discernable difference between actual location master shots, wherein you can see the actors starting to sweat, and the close-ups where they appear more made-up, “composed,” as it were. Check out the initial confrontation between Peck’s and Carroll Baker’s characters and the hooligans led by Chuck Conners for a pertinent example. Another interesting wrinkle in the home-theater high-def realm. It doesn’t detract from the overall, you know, majesty of the viewing experience. —A
Big Jake (Paramount)
A lesser latter John Wayne Western, and not exactly a paragon of narrative sleekness either; fiery opening notwithstanding, it takes a while to suss out just what the heck it’s actually ABOUT, anyway. A bold, zesty, colorful picture, which boosts some, um, interesting detail, e.g. Richard Boone’s big, sunburned nose. Also, a pissed-off middle aged Maureen O’Hara looks even more pissed off (but not more middle-aged, bless her) in high-def. For Duke nuts with Blu-ray players, a must. For everyone else, optional. B+
Black Moon (Criterion)
From my notes: “Damn, this twilight opening looks good! Agh, she killed a hedgehog! What’s up with that? There’s crappy radio reception. A commenter who sounds like Glenn Beck! Whoo-hoo! It’s all Hour of the Wolf, and La Chinoise and shit! Makes ya look at Malle a little differently, huh?” Louis Malle’s scrappy indie—a film he made, he said once, because he wanted to shoot something at his French countryside house—is another Alice In Wonderland rethink, this one a post ’68, post-apocalyptic one. It is more successfully (and mordantly) eccentric than the other Malle film we’ll be getting into later in this column….and I haven’t really made up my mind about the whole thing yet, and maybe never will. Which is a good thing in my book. As for the disc, I don’t think “nearly unbelievable” is going too far with respect to sizing up its image quality. Less fulsome observers may settle for revelatory. This is one of those things worth checking out strictly on that basis. I don’t think I’ve ever seen Sven Nykvist’s color work look better on home video before. Particularly striking ARE the aforementioned twilight scenes. Dusk is hard on high-def; if you don’t do the compression right, you’ll get a video-noise effect that’s distractingly smeary, particularly on some flat-panel screen. Here the image is clean as a whistle throughout, and gorgeous. Also from my notes: “REALLY REALLY BEAUTIFUL!” A+
The Cat O’Nine Tails (Blue Underground)
I’m not sure what the house is responsible for the high-def transfers of early Argento films that are going to Arrow and Blue Underground, and frankly I’m not sure if it’s a transfer issue or a material issue, but I’ve been noticing what strikes me as an odd consistency in the grain structure in the Blu-rays from both companies I’ve looked at of Deep Red, this film, and now Tenebre, recently from Arrow. That is, the grain is pretty heavy, to the point sometimes of looking like speckling. A good example on this particular disc comes about thirty minutes in; check out the hood of the blue Corvette in the scene, it looks speckled with white. Not to get all Jeff Wells or anything but I find this kind of distracting. I didn’t notice this so much on the excellent Blu-rays, from both Arrow and Blue Underground, of Argento’s Inferno, nor on the superb Arrow Blu-ray of Phenomena. But it is occasionally frustrating, to the point where it’s a bit of a fly in the ointment with respect to my enjoyment of the film. —B+
Crack in the World (Olive)
The quality of certain Olive masters hasn’t always been anything to write home about—to call the disc of Preminger’s Such Good Friends serviceable is almost overstating the case, frankly—but let’s face it, the label’s work largely indicates what the market will bear, as it were, so…anyway, I was a little surprised with how well I liked the look of this. DVD Beaver rates it pretty not-great, and I can see their point, but as I watched, I thought, Wow, this doesn’t look bad at all. It’s certainly not the most pristine in terms of pinpoint sharpness, but it does have substantial detail and color. As with certain other non-pristine Blu-rays in my experience, the overall look brought the Proustian rush of Saturday afternoon projections in the late ‘60s at Bergenfield’s Palace Theater. For those not familiar with said experience, I’ll say that it looks like good/decent vault print projected at proper brightness levels. But what’s with the soundtrack? There’s a lot of irritating discrepancy between the dialogue and music levels, aargh. Be advised, though, a lot of the disaster stuff is stock footage! There’s noticeable video noise at the world-turned orange finale. And there’s also chipmunk stock footage. And apparently the aspect ratio’s off, 1.78 rather than 1.85, but it’s not much of a bother. Lot of caveats for a disc I’m gonna recommend. What can I tell you, I’m a sucker for halfway decent cult items in high-def. —B
Don’t Look Back (Docurama)
Cool. Grainy. Scratchy. But awesome; beauteous documentary clarity. Dylan, what you’d call a legendary performer, to be sure. And a classic document, too. God, the London journalists are assholes, and as those of us who follow such things are well aware, the situation didn’t get a whole lot better when actual “rock critics” came into existence. But there was some improvement. Anyway, if you ever gave a damn about Dylan or the ‘60s or anything, you really ought to invest in this, as it seems a definitive home version. — A+
Drive Angry (Summit)
This proud-to-be-idiotic grindhouse pastiche really IS as dumb as it wants to be, and as bombastic, and is thus moderately impressive. The image quality on the disc is such that it almost (ALMOST) makes one wish one had a 3D display, Blu-ray player, etc. But this gets the job done without stereoscopic enhancement, and is a demo-disc hoot. —A
The Fall of the Roman Empire (Anchor Bay U.K. import, Region B locked)
Regulars of this blog know what a big Anthony Mann fan I am, and how highly I value this understated, elegiac epic. So of course they won’t be surprised that I sprung for a Blu-ray of it first chance I got, regardless of unpopular prices/exchange rates. And I’m glad I did. This looks real nice. There’s just a little color registration issue in some of the long shots, which is likely a materials issue or even a source issue stemming from anamorphic lens distortion or something. Nothing particularly major/distracting though. There’s a little shine/brightness in female lead Sophia Loren’s skin tones from time to time, she’s pretty heavily made-up and her natural olive complexion is covered and very white in certain shots. But the overall impression this gives is of just what a great VISUAL film this is throughout, always. Every shot is an impeccable composition and the flow from image to image is just breathtakingly effortless seeming. The diffused light in the forest battle about 50 minutes in is as spectacular an effect as Kurosawa himself ever captured. Everything holds together, remains solid, and as for beautifully telling details, check out the whites and pale blues of mad emperor Christopher Plummer’s eyes. —A
Hair (MGM/UA)
Talk about movies that don’t get better with age. You can see what director Milos Forman wanted to do with this—create something that seemed as free and loose and spontaneous as he imagined the American ‘60s counterculture might have been, should have been, whatever—but the intransigent material bests him. Thus, this 1979 film is a curio that just gets curiouser. This looks okay, nice autumn-in-Central-Park tones. But it doesn’t PLAY at all. And Treat Williams’ wig, or whatever it is. And that dude who ended up replacing terry Kath in Chicago. And it’s still better than Across the Universe. But not as inadvertently funny. —B-
Hannie Caulder (Olive Films)
This far-less-comedic-than-usual Burt Kennedy picture, a brisk 1971 revenge Western with a career-high performance from Raquel Welch (poor woman is set upon by Ernest Borgnine, Jack Elam and Strother Martin, all at their skeeviest) and a turn by Robert Culp that makes you wish he’d been way more prominent as a film actor, doesn’t look too shabby at all. A clean, detailed image for the most part —little video noise on the sand in a desert ride sequence but nothing to complain about past that on the visuals. The soundtrack is another matter. It’s even more all-over-the-place than that of Olive’s Crack in the World Blu-ray, with music WAY louder than dialogue throughout. It’s almost impossible to find a consistent volume level where you can hear the dialogue clearly but not be overpowered by the score. I’m an old hand at remote manipulation but that’ no way to watch a film and this disc gets docked down to its current grade from what might have been a solid B+ on that account. So: —C-
Heavy Metal (Sony)
A VERY handsome presentation! Too bad the film itself still kind of stinks. Well, mostly. Haven’t looked at this since its theatrical release, which I recall through a certain cannabis haze as a bit of a disappointment best exemplified by the fact that the title song was a solo turn by the member of The Eagles nobody gave a shit about. When was that, 1981? Yep. This time around, I notice a lotta what they call “Canadian content,” that the “Harry Canyon” segment set a lot of precedent for The Fifth Element, which Element largely picked up and ran with a lot better. And goofy art direction and limited animation and a lot of edgy-for-the-‘80s content, which subsists of lovingly drawn giant female breasts. Oh well. The aspect with the most entertainment value is John Candy’s voice work in the “Den” segment, in which he says things like “There was no way I was gonna walk around this place with my dork hanging out” in his Jerry-Mathers-as-The-Beaver tones. The disc is very crisp looking and the soundtrack, ostensibly an important aspect here, is solid.—B-
INLAND EMPIRE (Optimum U.K. import, Region B locked)
I remember when this first came out and a lot of would-be experts complained along lines of “Lynch can’t REALLY be happy with how this looks,” “how this looks” being an oft-smeary, muddy digital video, but hey, if you’ve seen the guys paintings, or the early shorts he made using the image sensors of video security cameras, you don’t have to strain very far at all to apprehend the purposefulness of the image and its quality. Lynch may be an intuitive artist, but he knows his eye, and what it wants. INLAND EMPIRE is what it is from its look down (or up). This look, this texture, whether you like it or not, is what he wanted, and a reflection of how/what he sees, at least for the purposes of this particular project. Deal. And in its indistinct smeariness it is sometimes quite beautiful. You get a lot of that early Sony cam shimmer, only in high-def and in black and white and color. As might be expected, the Blu-ray does a fine job of capturing it. This image quality is entirely appropriate to the content, which makes a lot of Laura Dern’s frequently frozen anguished facial expressions. Watching this film this time around—and as Lynch films go, this is a pretty difficult sit at times, but with real rewards—I discerned possible influence on Certified Copy, of all things. —A
Insignificance (Criterion)
This isn’t exactly at the top of the list of films I want to see get the Criterion Blu-ray treatment—if I may be so bold, may I mention Bad Timing? Eureka?—but in matters such as these I do generally adopt the Bachman-Turner Overdrive attitude, that is, I’ll take what I can get. I’ve seen a few critics bitch about the premise of this film’s scenario—you know, what if Marilyn Monroe met up with Albert Einstein who’s being hassled by Joe McCarthy who’s etc.—as being tiresome even as “what ifs?” go, and I am not unsympathetic. I also find Michael Emil a distinctly unengaging performer. Anyway: “What’d you see, did you see anything?” “I saw the face of God!” Such is the exchange between two technicians under the grating during a pastiche of the shooting of the upskirt biz in The Seven Year Itch, so you can guess the conclusion this picture comes to about the nature of the cosmos. Still. This looks really great, and the film does get better the further from the specifics of the premise you can get from it. Then you appreciate the real charm, say, of Tony Curtis’ sweaty performance—he’s not doing Joe McCarthy, he’s doing J. J. Hunsecker. —A
The Island (Paramount)
My favorite Michael Bay movie, not least because it’s in essence a multi-million-dollar remake of a cheesy, hysterically-premised sci-fi B‑picture that wound up as an MST3K episode. This concept appeals to the perverse formalist in me. Also because Scarlett Johansson looks especially good in it. Also because it packs some relatively exhilarating action scenes into its cheesy hysterical premise, which is less inane than that of the Transformers movies. In any event the image is beautiful and the salient extra, a commentary from the man himself, is worth the price of the disc. On the creative process: “That’s how you get ideas for movies, they come straight from real life.” On effects: “If you put a human being in a plastic bag with 150 gallons of KY Jelly in it…” well, don’t let me spoil that for you. On ScarJo:. “Not only is she a pain in the ass to work with and I mean that in the best way.” Finally, the maestro’s explication of the word “dude” explains A LOT. Check it out. —B+
Kiss Me Deadly (Criterion)
Grain-hater Jeffrey Wells wasn’t completely off base in his reports with respect to the seemingly variable grain on display here. The salient difference is that in no part of the film does anybody look “covered with bugs.” But at certain points the grain is heavier than it is at other points. But the disc looks absolutely tops overall,. The sharpness underscores just how the visuals are crucial above all else to the thoroughly modernist sense of alienation the film is so invested in—check out the shots of Mike and Velma framed in front of newish L.A. buildings after he leaves hospital…they’re practically Antonioniesque—while never losing the pulpiness of the surface content. Indeed, the 1955 film’s portrait of slick new L.A. in relief with its old quaint tendrils is a movie in and of itself. And love that answering machine! The Alain Silver/James Ursini commentary is very good, no surprise, and other extras are solid. You need this. —A+
The Lickerish Quartet (Cult Epics)
“Don’t take it so seriously, it’s only a film!” Sex-film pioneer Radley Metzger’s artiest picture, a kind of Teorema-in-reverse crossed with undergrad-level Robbe-Grillet is pretty exquisite in this high-def version. One character wears a mohair sweater, and really, it’s as if each particular hair is standing on end like quills upon the fretful porpentine. There’s a bit of audio-level discrepancy between music score and dialogue track but not NEARLY as noticeable as what’s on the Olive Blus. Besides that, some scratches at what look like reel-opening points but nothing to complain about otherwise. Also worth noting that Cult Epics discs ain’t cheap, so think about how much you really love ‘70s erotica before you commit to this.—A
The Long Riders (MGM/UA)
Damn, this is a really good movie. This Blu-ray sometimes strikes me as little on the “bright” side, but overall the image is very rich and burnished, looking best during, say, an overcast funeral scene. Watching Pamela Reed’s turn as a feisty prostitute, and enjoying her dorsal nudity, I had a weird flashback to working at Video Review magazine and reading a review of something-or-other by Jeffrey Lyons in which Lyons referred to Reed, apropos of nothing, really, as a “quiet, shy actress.” What a doofus. With respect to audio, again, a pretty big dynamic range difference between dialogue and music and it’s kind of annoying. —B+
Lord of the Rings Extended Edition (Warner)
Wow. Look at that shire. So green. So gorgeous. Okay, I’m just gonna come out and admit it: I have not watched this set, which runs about 700 hours, in its entirety. But I’ve looked at a good deal of it, and have been thoroughly impressed with every aspect of the presentation. It’s beautiful. And some time this year I WILL look at the whole thing, and not without pleasure; while I can’s be said to be a fully-fledged member of Team Hobbit, or whatever you want to call it, I have a lot of respect for the production achievement this trilogy represents. Although I still hold with my old wisecrack that the first film, The Fellowship of the Ring, is the greatest slideshow of Led Zeppelin album cover artwork ever created. In any event, consider my grade provisional. I’ll correct it if I find anything wrong, or even “wrong” with this. —A+
The Makioka Sisters (Criterion)
I do love when Criterion plucks a title out of not-quite-nowhere and spruces it up with a fresh-as-a-daisy presentation that renders it a commodity ripe for both discovery and reevaluation. Kon Ichikawa’s exquisite 1983 family saga isn’t really an unknown quantity, but it’s not revived hereabouts all that frequently. So this is a gift in many ways, one of which is evident from the very first frames, which include some breathtaking perspectives of cherry blossoms in bloom; the colors on this Blu-ray are some of the most gorgeous and distinctive that you’ll see outside of a vintage Minnelli picture. Just beautiful.—A+
The Man Who Would Be King (Warner)
Really pretty nice, and a long-overdue upgrade of one of Huston’s best latter films. Logo purists rejoice: the old Allied Artists logo is untouched as the picture! The image is pretty handsome. The compression jobbers did good work with the snow in particular. I found the image a lot more consistent than the DVD Beaver reviewer did. There’s some wear and tear visible but really nothing that represents a sharp falloff of quality, so I would tell you to buy with confidence. —A
New York, New York (MGM/UA)
Hey I forgot Casey Kasem was in this! Okay. So, there’s some aspect ratio weirdness at the beginning of this; the opening credits are kind of windowboxed, and then the picture settles into….yup, 1.66. This is one of Scorsese’s really difficult films; the deliberate contrast/mixology between the emotional extremes of the content and the pushing of cinematic artifice sometimes feels like the director’s trying to take the audience off of a particular with him; still, as Godard once put it, this finally is “un vrai film.” One that deserves a somewhat better treatment than it gets here, image-wise, I think. The picture is a little softish, without seeming overly digitally manipulated. But it hasn’t even got close to the bang I remember upon seeing it for the first time at the Ziegfeld when it opened. Though maybe that’s too much to ask. This is a good rendering for high-def, but not nearly as revelatory as that of Raging Bull.—A
People on Sunday (Criterion)
The 1930 once-in-a-career throwing together of Siodmak, Ulmer, Zinneman, Wilder and Siodmak, is a sui generis sort of fake documentary that sheds Expressionism like a loose skin and shimmies toward a version of pre-neo-realism. Or at least it’s pretty (or maybe just easy) to think so. In any event there’s really nothing else like this beautiful and slightly eerie fake doc, and this is a beautiful edition from the start (the restoration is not, as one might have expected, a Murnau house deal but a collab between EYE Film Institute Netherlands and Criterion itself). Oh, man, what fabulous silvery grain is evident right from the start. It’s like looking at an hour and fifteen minutes worth of animated precious metals. Just gorgeous! A real delight, disarming for being a little unexpected. —A+
Rio Lobo (Paramount)
Another triumph for logo originalists, this high-def master of Howard Hawks’ last picture begins with the Cinema Center Films logo, YES! And boy, look at that cast: David Huddleston…Sherry Lansing (man, do not fuck with her)…George Plimpton…Terrific details throughout, including the stuff you’re not meant to notice, for instance you can see the scratches on the superimposition text transparencies they opticalled into the guitar-picking montage for the credits! A most welcome gift for Hawks fans, and if you’re not a Hawks fan, why are you reading this blog?—A
The Stunt Man (Severin)
Severin, like the Metzger-curating label Cult Epics, likes to put out much-sought after specialty items at unpopular prices. Given the unpopularity of the prices, the product had better be pretty good, and this version of Richard Rush’s engaging meta-movie looks pretty good and has a bunch of extras attached. Perfection it is not: Some video noise is mixed with the grain…and Rush’s perhaps ill-advised infatuation with the telephoto lens yields a real sense of softness when he’s holding the shot at the tighter end of the zoom lens. But it looks damn good overall and even better during the outdoors scenes. Still hate that dinky score though. —A-
The Taking of Pelham One Two Three (MGM/UA Best Buy exclusive)
The original, not that Tony Scott thing that know-somethingish cinephiles of a certain stripe feel oddly compelled to stick up for. And so, a classic, grayish, urban ’70 look, courtesy of cinematographer Owen Roizman. VERY nicely captured for high-def. Terrific compression, exceptional sharp detail. Under the fluorescent lighting of the subway cars and the grim MTA offices, everyone looks a little not-very-good at least, and that’s awesome. Hector Elizondo’s character, what a pig. With Jerry Stiller as “Rico.” In short, everything that fucking French Connection Blu-ray SHOULD have been—A+
They Live (Eagle Pictures Italian import, Region B locked)
Good details (in the tradition of Richard Boone’s bulbous nose, here we have realistically pockmarked Roddy Piper), very solid if unspectacular. And a fabulous motion picture. The fact that Universal hasn’t put this master out domestically speaks very poorly of Universal, but also indicates a problem with respect to the activism of our consumer class. Fabulous.—A
Those Daring Young Men In Their Jaunty Jalopies/Houdini (Legend)
In the tradition of my review of the double-disc/double-feature Blu-ray of The Skull and The Man Who Could Cheat Death, I’m gonna rate this based on a viewing of only one of the films, so there. Not to say I’m NOT looking forward to checking out Ken Annakin’s very agreeable Jaunty Jalopies, but the underground cinephile pick is the very enjoyable biopic that most creditably pairs Tony Curtis with Janet Leigh and boasts one of Curtis’s most engaging, committed performances. The picture is great fun right from its “meet cute” opening for the leads. The master was clearly made from imperfect materials (there are some color registration issues in certain scenes), but overall it’s pretty handsome and vivid. It represents a small but appreciable boost in detail from the standard-def version, and there’s a whole other movie attached, the price is low, so yeah, this is a good value for the Curtis/Leigh lover. A-
True Grit (Paramount)
We’ve already argued as much as I care too about the film, which I think very highly of, but I can’t imagine there being any argument over this Blu-ray of it, which is just “Holy crap” flawless. Just beautiful. The color, the detail. The flame! The night scene(s). There’s a lot of difficult-to-resolve stuff here that’s resolved and depicted brilliantly. A true demo disc showcase piece.—A+
Wild At Heart (Universal U.K. import, region free)
Good detail and color. Grain skews toward noisy at times, which is a little bit of a surprise. Largely pretty good. Excellent sound. Which is, or should be no surprise. There’s a lot of grain increase/breakup during certain optical effects, such as the dissolves from Diane Lane’s wicked witch to burning window, but it’s not overly distracting. Also noticeable is diffusion (or is it vaseline on the lens) in the early exchanges between Ladd and Harry Dean Stanton. But overall the look is solid and vivid. A lot of people like to talk shit about this movie and its lack of, I dunno, coherence (or was it intelligence?), but who cares? As a sheer spectacle it’s AWESOME!—A
You Only Live Once (Eagle Pictures Italian import, Region B locked)
Another Italian job, that is, it’s from the same outfit that had the brains to put out They Live. I imagine the actual extant materials for this 1937 film, one of Fritz Lang’s best in Hollywood, are not pristine, but this version looks very solid throughout and this is likely the best it’s gonna look in a video format unless new materials are found or an extensive restoration is done. So Lang freaks with a multi-region player, you know what to do.—A
Zazie dans le metro (Criterion)
Whimsy might not have been Louis Malle’s most congenial climate, and his attempt to transpose the antic wordplay and pataphysical attitude of one of Queneau’s most enjoyable novel’s to the screen is not always on the mark—it’ll strike many as kind of conventional in its “Paris when it’s zany” trappings. Which might not be an entirely bad thing; the movie’s pretty accessible as a result. And it looks, in this version, like the platonic ideal of a bright and beautiful color ‘60s “new wave” film comedy. Intoxicating, in other words. Good extras too. Fun.—A
“He [Jean-Pierre Melville] begged us to turn our backs on what he considered to be misguided works like Johnny Guitar and to look instead to the American classics for inspiration. Biased as he was, he contended that only two–at that time, disdained–directors counted for anything at all; William Wyler and Robert Wise.” –Volker Schlondorff
Dear Glenn, if loving The Big Country more than The Fall of the Roman Empire is wrong, I don’t wanna be right.
By the by, as I should have added: This is splendid work and a real service to your devoted readers.
I love every word of these Consumer Guides and I don’t even own a Blu-Ray player. Nothing I read today will give me as much pleasure as this did. Now I just have to see The Long Riders, The Makioka Sisters, Black Moon, The Fall of The Roman Empire, etc etc.
Glenn, how’s the sound on that BIG COUNTRY disc?
I remember ALICE! I saw it with a bunch of friends who were playing an ill-advised “Said the White Rabbit” Drinking Game.
Glenn – great job, as usual.
Griff – the sound is mono on The Big Country (conflicting info as to whether or not the theatrical release had stereo prints), but sounds very full in lossless DTS_MA.
RE: The Big Country. Dear God how I love this film. I once had the chance to hang out a bit with Wyler’s daughter at a film festival, and we got to talking about them danged auteurists. I was surprised to learn that Wyler really was saddened by the fact that a lot of serious (or “serious”) critics didn’t care for much of his work, in particular this one. So there: You made William Wyler cry, auteurists!
Also, re: LOTR. I actually did just watch the entire film series (though not the extras, which I think are just the extras from the original DVDs and have not been updated for Blu-Ray), and I must say, it was eye-opening – seeing them together, you begin to notice some surprising stylistic echoes and reflections among the films.
Thanks Pete. Yeah, Griff, one of my shortcomings as a Blu-ray assessor is that unless there’s something WRONG with the sound, I tend to be pretty complacent about it, but I’ll just commend Pete’s comment; it’s a lossless mono track and it sounded just fine to my ears, clear and well-modulated across the board.
Insignificance is by far my favorite Jim O’Rourke album!
Bilge, the next time you see Ms Wyler, do remind her about Melville. 🙂 Meanwhile I will take the liberty of adding your name to my secret “Wyler Is TOO an Auteur” clubhouse membership list.
Glenn, I’m really glad that the sound on The Big Country is good, because Jerome Moross’ score is so glorious it’s practically another character.
Also very glad you share The Long Riders love. One of my favorite modern Westerns.
I third Bilge and the Siren re: THE BIG COUNTRY. An excellent and hugely underrated Western I first caught on HD cable earlier this year. So much great stuff, not just the widescreen visuals. I love the bit about country hats vs. city hats from the beginning. The horse-breaking stuff. And the Oedipal drama with antagonist ranchers to rival THE MAN FROM LARAMIE’s.
You’ve made me want to see THE LONG RIDERS again too.
ZAZIE I couldn’t take for more than about 15–20 minutes. It seemed insufferably hyperactive and cutesy to me. Nothing like what I imagined the writer of EXERCISES IN STYLE might produce as a film scenario. Nor really like any of Malle’s other films. I wish Bunuel had directed this instead. The hideous Criterion cover at least accurately reflects the experience of watching it.
Technical question about INLAND EMPIRE on Blu-ray from Glenn and anyone else who knows: What’s the upside to releasing this standard-def shot video in 1080p? Has the image been transferred to film first and then back? If not, can you really detect a difference in the image-quality between this and the regular DVD?
Yeah, thing about LONG RIDERS is it always looked out of place, visually, from the surrounding Walter Hill movies. Or maybe it’s just from seeing it mostly on old TV prints and over-bright VHS, but always thought it had some sunny, unfiltered, generic CBS TV movie visual style, as opposed to the bluesy bourbon-soaked grain and reds look of The Driver and 48 Hrs and Streets of Fire. Though I guess maybe Southern Comfort has a little of that over-bright unfiltered thing, too.
Wild at Heart has always looked pretty bad in every format.
I’m guessing there was more going on with Richard Boone’s nose than a sunburn. Still, he was one the most awesome dudes to ever stand in front of a camera. RIO CONCHOS needs a vid release, stat.
After seeing HICKEY & BOGGS again a few months back, I’m also wishing Robert Culp had been way more prominent as a director. Seems a real loss to me that he never helmed another feature.
THE BIG COUNTRY is a must. No need to dismiss it because it is a populist western. They certainly don’t make ’em like that anymore! Just listening to the score cracks a smile on my face.
LORD OF THE RINGS… these are not aging well I have to say. There were plenty of problems with them at the time, and these problems only seem to be growing with age. I think the problem was shooting all three at the same time, resulting in a certain ‘flatness’ in a lot of the dialogue scenes. It didn’t help that in order to meet deadlines Jackson was farming out scenes to his wife and sundry others to direct 2nd unit… I think the janitor even ended up shooting some of it (presumably Viggo’s coronation scene in ‘King’ – something that comes across as a moment from a particularly bad episode of Star Trek The Next Generation). Lots of cool shots and great music but not the all-time classics many claim them to be.
RIO CONCHOS is now on DVD, on a Shout! Factory double bill with TAKE A HARD RIDE. A nice package.
Wyler didn’t much care for THE BIG COUNTRY at the time (difficult shoot) but it holds up well on Blu-ray. A shame the extras from the laserdisc couldn’t be ported over.
Shh, don’t anybody tell Dave Kehr about this thread. All the Wyler love might make his head explode like Jeff Wells’ at a So-Cal Taco Bell.
Oh, and HICKEY & BOGGS will be available as part of the MGM Limited Edition Collection (MOD discs) on August 23.
That’s funny, MarkVH. But by the same token, I don’t want anyone to take my observations re Wyler as some kind of anti-Willie referendum. I think he was a great filmmaker, and I think “The Big Country” is a better than solid if not transcendentally great picture, and it, like all of the other Wylers I have on DVD, has a place on my “Auteurs” disc shelves.
+1 on name/ass-checking the marvelous Pamela Reed, who has by far the best performance in the superb LONG RIDERS. One of a generation of great character actresses we should’a seen in many more significant roles, and I suspect in another era we might’a. A short list: Reed, Diane Venora, Lisa Eichhorn, Veronica Cartwright, Brooke Adams, &c., &c…
Sure would also welcome more significant roles, as it were, for Mr. Hill. Homes hasn’t exactly flexed much since WILD BILL, by my reckoning, but he flexed mightily there and in the underrated GERONIMO.
Not at all, Glenn – never meant to imply that you’re in the Wyler-hating camp, just that in my reading of Kehr I’ve never found him to pass up a chance at a disparaging word against the man’s work, so reading all the praise in this thread might get him a bit riled.
And I’m totally with you on Wyler-as-great-filmmaker, as a quick survey of his filmography reveals an incredible run of great-to-near-great studio films (Best Years of Our Lives remains one of my favoritest ever), always immaculately produced and beautifully performed. I much prefer his work to someone like Capra’s, which might earn me some derision with this crowd (not that we need to compare, but still). Hell, I even like Wuthering Heights. A lot.
What a pleasure to read another blu-ray consumer guide. I’m glad to see Don’t Look Back and People On Sunday getting such high marks (already two of my all-time favorite discs) and thanks for the reminder that I need to pick up Lord of the Rings, Inland Empire and You Only Live Once.
Glenn, if you haven’t picked up Masters of Cinema’s Coeur Fidele yet, I urge you to do so in the strongest possible terms. Everything about that disc (the movie itself, the image quality, the painstaking care it took to get the transfer to run at the correct speed, the solo piano score) blew me away.
Wow, I write it and Robert Cashill makes it so! Can I get a Criterion Blu-Ray of RUGGLES OF RED GAP? 🙂 Thanks for the RIO CONCHOS/HICKEY & BOGGS news. I know the latter got a previous release, but it was apparently quite bad.
MarkVH: You must be seeing the “wrong” Capra films.
Wyler’s a mixed bag, but made a lot of good movies. Now that I have a TV that might it do it some justice, I’ll have to check out that BIG COUNTRY Blu.
jbryant, I’ll admit my exposure to Capra has been somewhat limited relative to other golden-agers, but I’ve seen a good number of what are traditionally considered the “right” Capra films. I have great fondness for It Happened One Night, Platinum Blonde, etc. (I’ll cop to never having seen You Can’t Take it With You), but as a whole his stuff hasn’t gotten me that excited (I do love me some Bitter Tea of General Yen, though). Nothing against him, mind you, and I adore some of the actors he worked with consistently (Jean Arthur, Barbra Stanwyck). Just prefer a lot of other canon guys, and never understood why Wyler often gets a bum rap while Capra is heralded as a master.
MarkVH: Without getting into a whole defense of Capra “thing,” I’ll just say that I suspect he generally gets more auteurist respect than Wyler because his films show more of a thematic consistency. Wyler worked in many more genres, and I don’t think he generated his own material (been too long since I read that Wyler bio to be sure). Not saying this is right or fair, just supposin’. Hawks worked in a lot of genres, too, but you always seemed to get his world view. Maybe not so much with Wyler?
I’ll also add that I think a lot of folks who are left cold by Capra’s most famous “post-Code” films find a lot to like in the earlier work. Your fondness for General Yen, Platinum Blonde and It Happened One Night suggest you might enjoy Forbidden, Dirigible, American Madness, The Miracle Woman and Ladies of Leisure, among others, if you can find them (none of them are as Sterbergian as Bitter Tea though).
Glenn thanx again for your column. A couple of niggling reservations about the otherwise sublime Italian disc of You Only Live Once/Sono Innoncente. Somehow, the person doing the encode has produced a slight squeeze on the image, so if you watch it up against the previous PAL DVDs taken from the same restored print everything is reproduced pinched, with an AR of around 1.31 instead of 1.33. And – again – someone goofed off during the encode and has allowed about a dozen lines of Italian translation to get through as hard coded while playing the disc back with “No Subs” setting. The majority of the translated lines are of radio broadcasts, songs or newspaper headlines so they are more or less diegetic non dialogue, but it looks like somone in the encode suite ballsed up and ticked too many lines to remain in Italian translation for the non subbed encode. (Clear as mud?)